People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This shop has been in Chelsea Market for as long as I can remember. I have been enjoying their brownies since college, maybe high school. My recent visit to the store brought back some wonderful memories. However, due to cutting back on sugar, I got four mini versions instead. The Double Chocolate Baby and Peanut Butter Baby were very good. Almond Baby was a bit too crunchy, though still very good. The Apple Cinnamon Baby was a blondie and my least liked, though still enjoyable. Due to my diet restrictions, these are not something I will eat regularly, but it's nice to have a small bite every once in a while. ”
“ My review will solely be on the brownies because I have not been to the location in Chelsea. My husband brought home some sample brownies from his work event. We tried the fat witch baby (brownie) snow baby (white chocolate brownie) and the caramel baby. They are so cute and tiny. They aren't fudgy or cake like. My daughter and I rated the fat witch baby as the best one, caramel came second and snow baby last I thought it was too sweet for me. They definitely are cute and pretty good but I do prefer a more fudgy brownie. ”
“ I've been to this bakery a couple of years ago. I was happy to receive a mixed pack of their brownies today. The brownies are not dry. They're moist and flavorful. The bakery is located inside Chelsea Market. It's clean and their employees are very helpful. Looking forward to my future visit. ”
“ I don't know much about this bakery, but we stumbled upon it exploring CHelsea Market. Packaging is cute. Evidently it's a different textured thick brownie that is really good. I'm glad they offer samples. Otherwise I don't think I would have purchased any because it was around $6-7 for one tiny square. I purchased a matcha brownie & a double chocolate chip? one. The matcha one was delicious, but short lived. The double chocolate chip I took home to my husband and he evidently enjoyed his as well. They had a sign advertising that they were in an episode of Sex andThe City. Although that didn't have any influence on me making a purchase. ”
“ We got a lot of gifts from here since the brownies tasted so good. I tried the honey baby and the combo of honey and brownie together tastes so good. ”
“ I would say the brownies are good but not great. Maybe as a baker myself, I have unrealistic expectations, but they are still fresh and tasty. They are soft but not really fudgy. The shop is conveniently located in Chelsea market. More of a grab and go place. Take a brownie with you for later! ”
“ Brownies were so nice and tasty, I kept going for more until I figured I had eaten the whole block. Definitely freshly baked as it was so nice and moist. Bonus - bought it during witching hour - at $1.75 each brownie, I had to go back for more. ”
Menu
Fat Witch Brownie Mix
$7.9927 Baby Assorted Witch Gift Box Assorted Brownies
$87.99Blonde Witch
$5.85Walnut Witch Brownie
$5.85Emerald City Witch Brownie
$5.85
About
Fat Witch Bakery
Welcome to Fat Witch Bakery, a delightful haven nestled within the bustling Chelsea Market in New York City. Renowned for their unique and mouthwatering brownies, this bakery has been a sweet staple for both locals and tourists alike. Since its inception, Fat Witch Bakery has captured the essence of comfort food with its indulgent treats, sparking nostalgia and joy in every bite.
- Authentic Brownie Creations: Fat Witch Bakery takes pride in their signature brownies, expertly crafted to appeal to a variety of palates. Whether you're craving a classic chocolate experience or something more adventurous like a matcha-infused treat, their selection never disappoints.
- Vegan and Vegetarian Options: Catering to a diverse clientele, this bakery offers numerous vegan and vegetarian choices, ensuring everyone can indulge without compromising their dietary preferences.
- Accessibility: With wheelchair accessibility and street parking available, Fat Witch Bakery welcomes all guests, including families and furry friends. The inviting atmosphere makes it a perfect pit stop for anyone exploring Chelsea Market.
Based on glowing reviews, it's clear that patrons cherish both the flavor and the experience at Fat Witch Bakery. Gordon Y. shares fond memories of enjoying their brownies since college, reminiscing about the nostalgia each bite evokes. Tai G. highlights the adorable, mini "Fat Witch Baby" brownies, reveling in the flavors but noting her preference for a fudgier texture. Lyn N. appreciates the moist and flavorful brownies, noting the cleanliness and supportive staff, creating a welcoming environment for all visitors.
Each guest seems to find a unique treasure in Fat Witch Bakery's offerings, ranging from caramel swirls to the irresistible Apple Cinnamon Baby blondie. The delightfully packaged treats make for excellent gifts, as Jecy L. found when presenting them to friends. It’s evident that these brownies, whether enjoyed on-the-go or shared as a special gift, provide a delightful experience that is hard to forget.
In conclusion, Fat Witch Bakery stands out not only for its delectable brownies but also for its commitment to inclusivity and customer satisfaction. With each visit, you are bound to discover a new favorite, making this bakery a must-stop for anyone with a sweet tooth in New York City. Don't forget to check them out, especially if you’re exploring Chelsea Market!
Book a table